the mysterious lack of mainstream interest in the death of Aaron Swartz.

Aaron Swartz

Aaron Swartz

This past weekend a 26-year-old young man in Brooklyn committed suicide by hanging. His name was Aaron Swartz. You may not have heard of him, but this blog post, the Internet, techdom today – all owe him a great deal.

Aaron has been in the tech spotlight for over a decade. He is credited with developing RSS (that little feed you can add to your email client so that you see when a web site has been updated). He worked with Reddit. Recently, he was in the news – and was awaiting trial – for stealing a bunch of articles from JSTOR to put on the net for public access. Apparently not for financial gain.

I don’t understand the technical stuff – but essentially, while Swartz was a student at Harvard (ironically), he used MIT’s network to access JSTOR. He began downloading thousands of articles, changing his IP address each time JSTOR peeps started getting suspicious. He eventually ended up figuring out how to get past the system, put his laptop in a closet in some building at MIT – the same closet a homeless man used to store his belongings – and downloaded millions of articles from the humanities’ database. Parties had settled (JSTOR abandoned civil charges), and everything was wiped clean…until a federal prosecutor decided in 2011 that Aaron deserved further punishment (after MIT contacted the authorities). At the time of his death Aaron was facing up to 50 years in federal prison if convicted of the crimes committed against MIT.

None of the articles I’ve encountered had explicit answers as to how a potential conviction might have affected Aaron’s decision to take his life, but almost all mentioned it. While Aaron suffered from depression, Aaron’s family made specific mention of his legal issues in their public statement: “Decisions made by officials in the Massachusetts US attorney’s office and at MIT contributed to his death.” As of today, 25,000 people have signed an online petition that asks the White House to remove the prosecuting attorney in Aaron’s case. (The charges have been dropped in light of Aaron’s death.)

If Twitter is anything to go by, the tech community is up-in-arms. But I realized today – the rest of the world has stayed pretty much silent. What gives?

We live in an exciting and malleable time, and sometimes I think we forget just how exciting it is. And what kind of implications there are. The Internet has changed everything – information is democratized, and we all have access to it. If knowledge is power, we’ve got a new playing field. Perhaps institutions that are typically in charge (governments, universities, corporations) aren’t too thrilled with it all, for understandable reasons. As a society, we’ve been taught to worry about technological progress, to fear the hacker. He has become different, the “Other.” He is not one of “us.” It’s kind of 1984.

I can’t pretend to know enough about the government’s or MIT’s side to make an educated judgment on what’s happened. I do know that from my perspective – someone who’s interested in tech but doesn’t understand it – there doesn’t seem to be a middle ground. It is often in those instances where there isn’t that middle ground that we should examine society’s narratives and dialogue surrounding the issues in question. If there isn’t a dialogue already, it’s time to start one; wherever we stand, get things out in the open and take the stigma and power out of uncomfortable issues. Right? Wrong? Let’s talk about it.

Bottom line: there is rarely something more tragic than losing someone who has so much left to give to the world. By all accounts, Aaron had only just begun.

Illuminating links to Aaron’s work and thoughts. How he read so many books in one year beats me-

How to get a job like mine

Aaron’s list of books to read

National suicide prevention lifeline: 1-800-273-TALK(8255)

Advertisements

6 responses

  1. Good post, saddening story. Thanks for putting this out there Jen.

    Do you know what the charges were exactly against him?

    1. From what I understand, he was charged under the “Computer Fraud and Abuse Act,” invoked in the 80s. I think some people believe the act is too broad and needs to be revisited. Having trouble finding the actual charges!

  2. Thank you so much for writing this thoughtful piece. I teach in a one-to-one laptop school and we aim to use open source tools/materials all the time. Access, I always tell the students, has revolutionized the way we live, learn, consume, do business. Aaron’s passing and the trial gives enormous perspective to this and is unfortunately not prompting many to action.

    1. Thanks so much for your comment! yes, it seems like a much more pressing issue than anyone has made it out to be.

  3. I want to thank you for bringing this to my attention. My love to him and his loved one’s. I had never heard of him until today, though I recognized some of the accomplishments you mentioned. 50 years for crimes of information?? This is so Big Brother it is scary. So it isn’t enough to give kids life in prison for mushrooms and let child molesters out after doing 2 of their 5 years, they have to steal the lives of people who’s only objective was the put the knowledge (the power) in the hands of the people getting fucked by Big Corp, Big Gov, Big brother. I’m surprised he was even going to get a trial, don’t they usually throw “Info-bandits” in Guantanamo?? And furthermore, are we all that sure he wasn’t murdered? Hit’s generally look like accidents or suicides when done by Big Brother and its corporate cohorts. The fact that information surrounding the case as well as his death are somewhat elusive doesn’t ease my mind or my paranoia. Here we had a representative of the people, the youth. Smart enough to do something against those who withhold knowledge and dangle it in front of us like a carrot. An “Everyman” with the balls and the brains to do something that would disrupt the power structure. You see, when we have access to information and learn it on our own time, the institutions “guarding” that knowledge looses its ability to mold us and our world view. Why do you think people with college educations think you have to have a degree to be credible. They’ve been molded by spending years in the institution. Granted that isn’t the rule or the exception, but it seems apparent to me. But most people think I’m “out there” anyway. Hope he’s in a better place now, or at least got a better view. We have lost an ally of the “information age.” Thanks for bringing it to my attention, I was just researching the back ground of 1984, this is one of the things that came up, thanks again.

    1. very cool – yeah, i haven’t heard really anything about all of it since i wrote this!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Andrew James Taggart, Practical Philosopher, Ph.D.

Do You Want to Lead the Most Excellent Human Life?

Donald Robertson

Stoic Resilience Blog

INALJ

Information professionals finding & sharing jobs & job hunting advice!

Millennial

Young Catholics, An Ancient Faith, A New Century

%d bloggers like this: